I think the top three three classic Genesis albums for me are
- Selling England by the Pound
- A Trick of the Tail
- Wind and Wuthering
All the other albums are fantastic in their own right. but those are the three for me
The Lamb has some great music, but, like a lot of double albums (IMO), is spread too thin. Put all the good ideas on a single album and it would have been great. I’ll posit that the only double LP I have ever heard that is 5 star from start to finish is ELO’s “Out of the Blue”…
I always felt that Geneis survived the departure of Gabriel relatively well, as evidenced by the two fine albums that followed, but the loss of Hackett, whilst less high profile, was far more of a blow to the music. Possibly also they were on the cusp of having to change to the shorter song form, as most prog bands in that era did, but the albums that followed did miss Hackett’s innovative guitar. Think of all of the ideas on “Please Don’t Touch”, “Spectral Mornings” or “Defector” that could have graced a Genesis album. After Defector, Hackett himself moved into different directions.
If you haven’t checked it out, do listen to his new “At the edge of light album” it’s his best for ages. I also like his “Squakett” collaboration with Chris Squire.
Also, his two “Genesis Revisited” albums are very good - the first one is quite interpretive of the songs, but the second is more true to the originals, but you get more modern recordings of the classics, along with some surprise guests like Nik Kershaw!
The Tokyo tapes is also a very fine live album (from the Genesis Revisted 1 era) with an amazing band comprising, Hackett (no shit, Sherlok!), Chester Thompson, John Wetton, Ian McDonald and Julian Colbeck
And now it’s my thread, I can go as OT as I like!
I also think that Mike Rutherford is one of the most underrated bass players ever. Listen closely to what he is doing on those classic albums, and few bass players would come close.
I also think that Tony Banks never had the solo success he deserved. Out of the “And Then There were three” era Genesis line up and their respective solo output, I think his solo albums have stood the test of time the best. Well worth checking out if you never have. One of my favourite tracks is from his film soundtracks work - a collaboration with Toyah Wilcox call “Lion of Symmetry”. It’s keyboard hook is so simple, but an ear worm. It’s in my head now, and I haven’t even played it!