I compared the Tonex SVT with Brainworx in context of a full mix and Brainworx completely outclassed this particular Tonex profile. The biggest issue was the inability to tweak the Tonex amp knobs in an effective manner. You’re stuck with a particular sound only brighter or more muffled, more boomy or less boomy. I own a Sansamp Bass DI and I’ll compare it too, but suspect the same outcome.
For me, amp sim vs profiler isn’t a matter of which is best, its two different tools for two different jobs. For me, the appeal of profiling is to capture my own amps at specific settings that are used in a set list, and even expand to settings I would like to use but cannot because of “how to change them in the middle of a song?” Profiles fix all of that. So imo, as long as you have a profile of a setting you know you want for a particular song, profiling is great. But they are not flexible the way a real amp or a good sim is.
So for me anyway, Tonex would be to capture my real amps, all of which I’ve modified the voicing and gain to suit me. Good sims to do stock amps I don’t own.