From my tally, “A” was the ultimate choice, with “B” the penultimate choice, and “C” the least favorite.
This is why a blind test works well. There is no prejudice, nor brand favoritism.
I used mostly default settings on all three Leslies. The B5 organ was full out drawbars, with added C3 vibrato/chorus. This test may surprise some, but it didn’t really shock me. Below is why.
The “A” Leslie was the B5 resident Leslie. I have written many times about version 3 B5. I noticed the huge difference when I first used it. Version 2 wasn’t bad, except for the distortion…not good. Acoustic Samples prides itself with realism. It is my favorite live gigging organ. I do use the others as well. They are like my children, and I know what to expect from them, concerning the need of the song.
“B” was the 2nd choice. It was the UVI Rotary which @Sergio and I were discussing. If y’all remember, it was the winner of the blind test we did a few years ago…very surprising at the time. The problem I find with Rotary is it’s highs were too much, but very little mid and low. I tried in vain to balance the horn and drum. An E.Q. would help, but that wasn’t available. It has a selection of cabs, such as 122, 145, 722, 760 and so on, but I honestly heard very little, if any difference. With some time, I might be able to tame it, but I was going with default settings. It works best with Guitar, and E-Pianos.
Lastly…(drum roll) was IK Multimedia Leslie. When not using default settings, I can dial in a great sound in IK. @Torsten said everything I felt above… it sounds “flat”. I love the IK Hammond, but for me, in a live situation, it can’t touch the B5v3 feel. I find myself playing much better using B5. I moved the IK Hammond into most of my songs over a year ago, but I go to B5 on new songs. Again, it’s all about feel, and “flat” seems to describe it best. A great plug though!
I use Blue3 (much better in the newest version…thank you Ray!), VB3 1.4, but stopped using VB3 II. Hopefully the new, upcoming VB3 will be as good as the app version. Kinda like coming full circle.
Again, thank you all for participating. Will hopefully post some new presets next week!!
Cheers to all
Corky